Version: Latest

ActionResult Refactoring Migration Guide

Overview

This guide covers the migration from ActionResult v1.x (monolithic) to v2.0 (component-based). While the refactoring maintains 100% backward compatibility, understanding the new architecture enables more powerful and maintainable code.

Quick Reference

No Breaking Changes

If you're only consuming ActionResult, no code changes are required. All existing methods continue to work exactly as before.

Architecture Changes

v1.x: Single 1113-line class handling all responsibilities
v2.0: Facade delegating to 12 focused components (each less than 300 lines)

Component Mapping

Where Did My Code Go?

Original ActionResult Method	New Component	Component Method
`add(Match...)`	MatchCollection	`add(Match...)`
`sortMatchObjects()`	MatchCollection	`sortByScore()`
`getBestMatch()`	MatchCollection	`getBest()`
`getMedian()`	MatchStatistics	`getMedianRegion()`
`addString(String)`	TextExtractionResult	`addText(String)`
`getActiveStates()`	StateTracker	`getActiveStates()`
`getDuration()`	TimingData	`getElapsed()`
`addDefinedRegion(Region)`	RegionManager	`defineRegion(Region)`
`addMovement(Movement)`	MovementTracker	`recordMovement(Movement)`
`addSceneAnalysis(SceneAnalysis)`	ActionAnalysis	`addSceneAnalysis(SceneAnalysis)`

Migration Patterns

Pattern 1: Basic Usage (No Changes Needed)

// This code works identically in v1.x and v2.0
ActionResult result = action.execute(objectCollection);
if (result.isSuccess()) {
    Optional<Match> best = result.getBestMatch();
    List<Location> locations = result.getMatchLocations();
    result.print();
}

Pattern 2: Enhanced Component Access

// Old way - limited to ActionResult methods
ActionResult result = action.execute(objectCollection);
// Had to use multiple methods to analyze matches
result.sortMatchObjectsDescending();
Match best = result.getBestMatch().orElse(null);
List<Match> filtered = new ArrayList<>();
for (Match m : result.getMatchList()) {
    if (m.getScore() > 0.8) filtered.add(m);
}

// New way - direct component access for advanced operations
ActionResult result = action.execute(objectCollection);
MatchCollection matches = result.getMatchCollection();
MatchStatistics stats = matches.getStatistics();

// Rich component APIs
matches.sort(SortStrategy.SCORE_DESCENDING);
List<Match> highConfidence = matches.filterByMinScore(0.8).getMatches();
double avgScore = stats.getAverageScore();
ConfidenceLevel confidence = stats.getConfidence();

Pattern 3: Building Results

// Old way - imperative construction
ActionResult result = new ActionResult();
result.setSuccess(true);
result.setActionDescription("Click login button");
for (Match match : foundMatches) {
    result.add(match);
}
result.setStartTime(startTime);
result.setEndTime(endTime);
result.setDuration(Duration.between(startTime, endTime));

// New way - fluent builder pattern
ActionResult result = new ActionResultBuilder()
    .withSuccess(true)
    .withDescription("Click login button")
    .withMatches(foundMatches)
    .withTiming(startTime, endTime)
    .build();

Pattern 4: Statistical Analysis

// Old way - manual calculations
ActionResult result = action.execute(objectCollection);
double totalScore = 0;
for (Match m : result.getMatchList()) {
    totalScore += m.getScore();
}
double avgScore = totalScore / result.size();

// New way - built-in statistics
ActionResult result = action.execute(objectCollection);
MatchStatistics stats = result.getMatchCollection().getStatistics();
double avgScore = stats.getAverageScore();
double stdDev = stats.getScoreStandardDeviation();
ConfidenceLevel confidence = stats.getConfidence();
Optional<Region> boundingBox = stats.getBoundingBox();

Pattern 5: State Tracking

// Old way - basic state list
ActionResult result = action.execute(objectCollection);
Set<String> states = result.getActiveStates();
// Limited information about state activity

// New way - rich state tracking
ActionResult result = action.execute(objectCollection);
StateTracker tracker = result.getStateTracker();
Optional<String> mostActive = tracker.getMostActiveState();
int activationCount = tracker.getActivationCount("LoginScreen");
List<Match> stateMatches = tracker.getMatchesForState("LoginScreen");
Map<String, Integer> summary = tracker.getStateSummary();

Advanced Usage

Custom Analysis Storage

// Store custom analysis data
ActionAnalysis analysis = result.getActionAnalysis();
analysis.addCustomAnalysis("gameState", new GameState(health, mana, score));
analysis.addCustomAnalysis("uiLayout", detectLayout(result));

// Retrieve with type safety
Optional<GameState> gameState = analysis.getCustomAnalysis("gameState", GameState.class);

Performance Metrics

// Access detailed performance metrics
ActionMetrics metrics = result.getActionMetrics();
long execTime = metrics.getExecutionTimeMs();
double retryOverhead = metrics.getRetryOverheadPercentage();
Map<String, Long> phaseTimings = metrics.getPhaseTimings();

// Track phases
metrics.recordPhase("imageSearch", searchDuration);
metrics.recordPhase("verification", verifyDuration);
long avgSearchTime = metrics.getAveragePhaseTime("imageSearch");

Execution History

// Track complex action chains
ExecutionHistory history = result.getExecutionHistory();
history.recordStep(new ActionRecord(...));

// Analyze execution
double successRate = history.getSuccessRate();
List<ActionRecord> failures = history.getFailedSteps();
String timeline = history.formatTimeline();

Testing Improvements

Component-Focused Testing

@Test
void testMatchFiltering() {
    // Test specific component behavior
    MatchCollection matches = new MatchCollection();
    matches.add(lowScoreMatch, midScoreMatch, highScoreMatch);
    
    MatchCollection filtered = matches.filterByMinScore(0.7);
    
    assertThat(filtered.size()).isEqualTo(2);
    assertThat(filtered.contains(highScoreMatch)).isTrue();
    assertThat(filtered.contains(lowScoreMatch)).isFalse();
}

Mocking Components

@Test
void testActionWithMockedComponents() {
    // Create result with specific component states
    ActionResult result = new ActionResultBuilder()
        .withMatches(mockMatches())
        .withStates(mockStateTracker())
        .withMetrics(mockMetrics())
        .build();
    
    // Test behavior with controlled components
    assertThat(result.getStateTracker().getMostActiveState())
        .contains("ExpectedState");
}

Performance Optimizations

Lazy Component Access

// Components are created on first use
ActionResult result = new ActionResult();

// No MatchCollection created yet
result.isSuccess(); // Doesn't create MatchCollection

// MatchCollection created here
result.add(match); // Creates MatchCollection on demand

Efficient Batch Operations

// Inefficient - multiple iterations
for (Match m : result.getMatchList()) {
    if (m.getScore() > 0.8) process(m);
}
for (Match m : result.getMatchList()) {
    if (m.getStateObjectData() != null) track(m);
}

// Efficient - single iteration with component
MatchCollection matches = result.getMatchCollection();
matches.getMatches().stream()
    .filter(m -> m.getScore() > 0.8)
    .forEach(m -> {
        process(m);
        if (m.getStateObjectData() != null) track(m);
    });

Common Pitfalls and Solutions

Pitfall 1: Modifying Internal Collections

// DON'T - Modifying internal collection
List<Match> matches = result.getMatchList();
matches.clear(); // Dangerous!

// DO - Use component methods
result.getMatchCollection().clear();

Pitfall 2: Assuming Component Existence

// DON'T - Components might be null in edge cases
int count = result.getMatchCollection().size(); // Could NPE

// DO - Null-safe access
int count = result.getMatchList().size(); // Facade handles nulls

Pitfall 3: Mixing Old and New Patterns

// DON'T - Inconsistent usage
result.sortMatchObjects(); // Old method
MatchCollection matches = result.getMatchCollection();
matches.filterByMinScore(0.8); // New method

// DO - Choose consistent approach
// Either use facade methods throughout
result.sortMatchObjects();
List<Match> filtered = result.getMatchList().stream()
    .filter(m -> m.getScore() > 0.8)
    .collect(Collectors.toList());

// Or use components throughout
MatchCollection matches = result.getMatchCollection();
matches.sort(SortStrategy.SCORE_DESCENDING);
MatchCollection filtered = matches.filterByMinScore(0.8);

Debugging Tips

Component Inspection

// Debug specific components
System.out.println("Matches: " + result.getMatchCollection().format());
System.out.println("Timing: " + result.getTimingData().format());
System.out.println("States: " + result.getStateTracker().format());
System.out.println("Regions: " + result.getRegionManager().format());

Performance Analysis

// Analyze performance bottlenecks
TimingData timing = result.getTimingData();
timing.addSegment("search", searchTime);
timing.addSegment("verify", verifyTime);
timing.addSegment("action", actionTime);

System.out.println("Total: " + timing.getElapsed());
System.out.println("Overhead: " + timing.getOverhead());
System.out.println("Breakdown: " + timing.format());

Recommended Practices

For New Code

Use ActionResultBuilder for construction
Access components directly for advanced operations
Leverage statistics for analysis
Store custom data in ActionAnalysis
Track performance with ActionMetrics

For Existing Code

No immediate changes required - code continues to work
Gradually adopt components as you modify code
Use builder pattern when creating new results
Add metrics tracking for performance monitoring
Enhance testing with component-level assertions

API Compatibility Matrix

Feature	v1.x Support	v2.0 Facade	v2.0 Components
Basic Operations	✅	✅	✅
Sorting	✅	✅	✅ Enhanced
Filtering	Limited	✅	✅ Enhanced
Statistics	Basic	✅	✅ Enhanced
Custom Analysis	❌	✅	✅
Performance Metrics	Basic	✅	✅ Enhanced
Execution History	Basic	✅	✅ Enhanced
Type Safety	Partial	✅	✅

Summary

The ActionResult v2.0 refactoring provides:

100% backward compatibility - No breaking changes
Enhanced capabilities - Richer APIs through components
Better testability - Focused component testing
Improved maintainability - Single responsibility principle
Future-proof architecture - Easy to extend

Whether you continue using the facade API or adopt the component-based approach, your code will benefit from the improved architecture, performance, and maintainability of the refactored ActionResult.

Overview​

Quick Reference​

No Breaking Changes​

Architecture Changes​

Component Mapping​

Where Did My Code Go?​

Migration Patterns​

Pattern 1: Basic Usage (No Changes Needed)​

Pattern 2: Enhanced Component Access​

Pattern 3: Building Results​

Pattern 4: Statistical Analysis​

Pattern 5: State Tracking​

Advanced Usage​

Custom Analysis Storage​

Performance Metrics​

Execution History​

Testing Improvements​

Component-Focused Testing​

Mocking Components​

Performance Optimizations​

Lazy Component Access​

Efficient Batch Operations​

Common Pitfalls and Solutions​

Pitfall 1: Modifying Internal Collections​

Pitfall 2: Assuming Component Existence​

Pitfall 3: Mixing Old and New Patterns​

Debugging Tips​

Component Inspection​

Performance Analysis​

Recommended Practices​

For New Code​

For Existing Code​

API Compatibility Matrix​

Summary​